Industry-Education Integration: Modeling Dilemmas and Practical Tensions
The integration of industry and education in vocational education is a key Chinese strategy to tackle structural talent imbalances. Through the lenses of model, relation, and institution theory, this study examines its development and dilemmas. Findings reveal: at the micro level, conflicts between corporate technical secrecy and educational publicity hinder knowledge transfer; at the meso level, vague stakeholder roles and weak incentives lead to superficial collaboration (“enthusiastic schools, cold enterprises”); at the macro level, uniform policies ignore regional industrial disparities. To address these, breakthroughs are essential: an integrated cross-level analytical framework, localized risk-benefit sharing mechanisms, and proactive digital ecosystem development. Ultimately, a layered, synergistic institutional ecosystem is crucial for linking the education, talent, industry, and innovation chains effectively.
References
- Wang Yanan and Wang Bin: Why "Substantial in Form but Weak in Reality": An Analysis of the Crux of the Entity Reform of Industry-Education Integration in Vocational Education, Education Research Monthly, Vol. 2025 (2025) No.4, p.95-103.
- Zhu Hongping, Zhu Ruizhe, Ye Hongwu et al.: Dilemmas and Breakthroughs in Developing Digital Resources for Vocational Education: Model Reconstruction Leveraging the Advantages of AI Technology, Journal of Distance Education, Vol. 43 (2025) No.3, p.64-72.
- Yue Wei, Li Wenjuan and Chen Junyuan: The Connotation, Composition and Development Path of Green Skills in International Vocational Education, Comparative Education Review, Vol. 46 (2024) No.8, p.7-19.
- Zhu Dequan and Shen Jiale: The Economic Logic of Vocational Education Serving Rural Revitalization: Neo-Endogenous Dynamics and Mechanisms, Education and Economy, Vol. 38 (2022) No.3, p.25-34.
- Song Yafeng, Wang Shibin and Pan Haisheng: A Spatial Econometric Study on the Efficiency of Regional Resource Allocation in Higher Vocational Education, Research in Higher Education of Engineering, Vol. 2019 (2019) No.1, p.144-151.
- H. Etzkowitz: The Triple Helix: Innovation in Academia, Industry and Government - Selected Writings of Henry Etzkowitz (Trans. Chen Jin, Tsinghua University Press, China 2016).
- K. Marx: Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 (People’s Publishing House, China 2000).
- J.A. Schumpeter: The Theory of Economic Development (China Commerce Publishing House, China 2009).
- C. Freeman: Technology Policy and Economic Performance: Lessons from Japan (Trans. Zhang Yuxuan, Southeast University Press, China 2008).
- Sun Shanxue: Thoughts and Suggestions on Improving the Vocational Education College Entrance Examination System, China Higher Education Research, Vol. 2020 (2020) No.3, p.92-97.
- Liu Bin, Zou Jiquan and Liu Xiaomei: The Logical Starting Point and Ideal State of Industry-Education Integration in Vocational Education, China Higher Education Research, Vol. 2017 (2017) No.11, p.106-110.
- He Yangyong: Institutional Reflection on Combining Work with Learning and School-Enterprise Cooperation in Higher Vocational Education, China Higher Education Research, Vol. 2009 (2009) No.2, p.70-72.
- Luo Yingzi, Zhang Zhiyuan and Chen Erdong: Conceptual Perspective, Type Distinction and Conceptual Evolution of Combining Work with Learning - Also on Its Enabling Effect on Professional Degree Graduate Education, Tsinghua Journal of Education, Vol. 46 (2025) No.1, p.55-67.
- Cao Keyan: Deepening Industry-Education Integration in Vocational Education: From the Dual Perspectives of Technology and Education, Education Research Monthly, Vol. 2025 (2025) No.3, p.38-44.
- Chen Nianyou, Zhou Changqing and Wu Zhuping: The Connotation and Realization Approaches of Industry-Education Integration, China University Science & Technology, Vol. 2014 (2014) No.8, p.40-42.
- Qiu Hui and Fan Qian: The Dynamic Mechanism and Strategy for Promoting Deep Industry-Education Integration, Heilongjiang Researches on Higher Education, Vol. 2016 (2016) No.12, p.102-105.
- Xie Xiaozhen: Research on the Mechanism of "Industry-Education Integration" and Its Path for Institutional Design, Research in Higher Education of Engineering, Vol. 2019 (2019) No.5, p.81-87.
- He Xingyue et al.: The Paradigm of Industry-Education Integration in Modern Higher Vocational Education (Zhejiang University Press, China 2018).
- Cai J.M., Xia L. and Yu G.J.: Connotation Cognition and Mechanism Innovation of Industry-Education Integration in Application-Oriented Universities, China University Science & Technology, Vol. 2019 (2019) No.4, p.4-7.
- Ma Wanli: Dilemmas and Pathways for Cultivating High-Level Talent in Key Core Technology Fields: From the Perspective of School-Enterprise Symbiosis, China Higher Education Research, Vol. 2023 (2023) No.7, p.53-60.
- Ji Chengjun and Fan Fengfu: Changing the Problem of "Enthusiastic Schools but Cold Enterprises" in Cooperative Talent Training, China Higher Education, Vol. 2011 (2011) No.12, p.56-57.
- Zhuang Xizhen: Internal Contradictions and Solutions for Industry-Education Integration, China Higher Education Research, Vol. 2018 (2018) No.9, p.81-86.
- Hu Changsong and Zhang Junping: Industry-Education Integration in Higher Vocational Education: Essence, Models and Pathways - From the Perspective of Knowledge Production Mode, China Higher Education Research, Vol. 2019 (2019) No.4, p.92-97.
- Li Yuan: Multiple Institutional Logics in the Construction of Mixed-Ownership Industry Colleges in Higher Vocational Institutions, Education Research Monthly, Vol. 2021 (2021) No.6, p.33-38.
- Kuang Ying and Han Lin: Development Opportunities, Practical Challenges and Breakthrough Paths for Constructing City-Based Industry-Education Consortiums, Modern Education Management, Vol. 2025 (2025) No.4, p.111-119.
- Hu Shunyi and Ouyang Yuliang: A Comparative Study of Provincial Industry-Education Integration Pilot Policies in China, Vocational Education, Vol. 22 (2023) No.32, p.3-9.
- Yin Yuhui, Jin Jin and Zong Cheng: Current Situation, Dilemmas and Promotion Strategies for Building Industry-Education Integration Communities: A Research Report Based on Reform and Innovation in Vocational Education, Vocational & Technical Education Forum, Vol. 40 (2025) No.1, p.31-38.